Christie's may have a difficult time breaking the single-auction record today. The Art Newspaper reports the auction house is considering removing the work from the sale. Andrew Lloyd Webber was attempting to sell the work, estimated at $60 million, with the proceeds going to charity. The work, from Picasso's blue period, was also the subject of a Federal District Court Case, dismissed yesterday.The dismissal has not been published yet on Lexis, but the New York Times has an overview of the claimant's case. Judge Jed Rakoff dismissed the claims because the federal law dealing with Holocaust restitution was inapplicable in this case. I'm not an expert on holocaust litigation, so I'm not sure which law the NYT is talking about. Apparently, the claimant has a case in New York state court however.
The claims seem tenuous to me at first blush. The plaintiff, Mr. Schoeps, is the heir of Paul von Mendelssohn-Barthold, a wealthy Berlin banker and art collector. He was forced to sell all his paintings as a result of Nazi persecution. The Nazi's didn't actually take the painting, but they seized his assets so that he had no choice but to sell the work. The ruling was just issued yesterday. I'll try to get my hands on the dismissal and look at the substance of the claims. To me, though, it seems like the claimant will have a very difficult time winning the case. We shouldn't underestimate the underlying equities of a case either, Lloyd Webber was selling the work in order to donate the proceeds to charity. Though Mr. Schoeps story is indeed a tragic one, I'm not sure he will be using the work, or its proceeds, in as charitable a manner.
No comments:
Post a Comment